What to do when a customer leaves a bad review
Reply once, calmly, and write it for the next customer reading. Google and Facebook only take down reviews that break their rules, not ones you find unfair.
The short answer
Reply once, promptly and briefly. Write it for the next customer who reads it, not the person who left it. Say sorry for the part that was on you, put your side in one plain sentence and offer a phone call. Google and Facebook remove reviews that break their rules, not reviews you think are unfair.
Give it an hour before you type
A one-star review stings. You’ve spent the afternoon under someone’s sink, you’ve gone back to fix something that wasn’t your fault, and now there’s a public post saying you’re a cowboy. The urge is to answer straight away and set the record straight.
Don’t. Write the reply, leave it, do something else, then read it back. Google’s guidance on replying to reviews says to reply promptly, because it shows you value what customers say. Promptly means today or tomorrow. It doesn’t mean the ten minutes after you’ve read it with your blood up.
If you’re still angry when you read it back, ask someone who wasn’t on the job to read it too. They’ll spot the line that sounds sarcastic before a customer does.
Who your reply is really for
The person who left the review has mostly made up their mind. Your reply is for the next person: say a homeowner in Wigan comparing three electricians on Google Maps, scrolling through the reviews to see what you’re like when things go wrong. They can’t know who was right about a job they weren’t at. What they can see is how you behave in public when someone has a go.
In our view, a calm, specific reply under a bad review does you more good than a perfect five-star row with no replies at all. It shows a real firm with a real person behind it, which is what people are looking for when they let a stranger into their house.
There’s another reason to get it right. Google’s help page on managing reviews says the person who wrote the review is notified when you reply, and that they can still change their review afterwards. A decent reply won’t always win anyone round, but it’s the only thing that gives you a chance.
How to write the reply
Google’s own tips on replying are sensible, and they line up with what we’d tell any tradesperson. Keep it short. Use the person’s name. Say sorry where it’s due. Own the mistakes you actually made, but don’t accept the blame for things that weren’t in your control. For anything complicated, politely ask them to get in touch by phone or email instead of having it out in public. Sign off with your name or initials.
So the shape is:
- Thank them by name for letting you know.
- Say sorry for the specific thing that went wrong, if it did.
- Give your side in one sentence of plain fact, with no argument.
- Offer to sort it, and say how to reach you.
- Sign off with your first name.
Say a plumber in Stockport gets two stars and this: “Turned up an hour late and left a mess in the bathroom.” A reply that works might read:
“Thanks for letting us know, Karen. You’re right, we were an hour late on Tuesday and we should have rung ahead. Sorry about that, and about the tidy-up. If you’re happy to, drop us an email and we’ll pop back and sort the bathroom out. Dave”
That’s four sentences. It doesn’t explain the traffic on the M60 or the job before that overran. The next reader sees someone who owns it and offers to fix it, and that’s all they need.
Now say a joiner in Bury gets one star from a name they don’t recognise, with no detail. The reply stays just as calm: “We can’t find a job booked under this name. If we’ve done work for you, please email us so we can look into it and put it right.” That reads well to the next customer, and it puts it on record that you checked.
Then stop. One reply, not a back and forth. If they reply again in public, answer in private.
The three replies that make it worse
The argument
The point-by-point rebuttal, the “actually, if you’d read the quote”, the “we’ve been doing this twenty years”. Even when every word is true, it reads as defensive to someone who wasn’t there. Google’s guidance says not to make personal attacks, and replies have to follow Google’s content policies like any other contribution. That policy treats unsubstantiated allegations of unethical behaviour or criminal wrongdoing as offensive content, so calling a customer a liar or a chancer in public can get your reply turned down.
The overshare
Their address, what they paid, the row on the doorstep, the fact they still owe you for the extra socket. Google says not to share a reviewer’s private information, and its content policy says personal information isn’t to be posted without consent. Keep the details for the private conversation.
The deal
“We’ll knock 20% off if you take this down.” It’s tempting when a review is costing you work, but Google says offering incentives in exchange for removing negative reviews is prohibited. Fix the problem because it’s the right thing to do, and leave the review where it is. If they change it of their own accord afterwards, that’s up to them.
The copy-paste reply sits just behind those three. Google advises against generic replies, and “Sorry you feel that way, please contact us” under every complaint tells the next reader nobody actually read it.
What Google will take down, and what it won’t
Google’s help page on reporting reviews is blunt: only reviews that break Google’s policies can be removed. It says not to report a review just because you disagree with it or don’t like it, and that Google doesn’t step into disputes between a business and its customers. A harsh but genuine review of a real job stays up, however unfair it feels.
What Google’s prohibited and restricted content policy does cover, and what’s worth knowing as a tradesperson:
- Reviews that aren’t based on a real experience. Google says fake engagement isn’t allowed and will be removed.
- Conflicts of interest, which the policy says can include current or former employment, industry competitors and family relationships.
- Content posted on a competitor’s business to undermine its reputation.
- Off-topic posts. The policy says contributions should be based on experience of a specific place, and rules out general political or social commentary and personal rants.
- Offensive content, including those unsubstantiated allegations of wrongdoing.
- Personal information posted without consent, plus harassment, hate speech and profanity used to offend.
So a review from a former apprentice with a grudge, or from the firm down the road, is worth reporting. A customer saying your price was too high isn’t.
How to report a review on Google
Google’s help page gives two routes. From your Business Profile on Google Search or Maps, open the reviews, choose the report option next to the one you want to flag, pick the reason and send it. Or use Google’s Reviews Management Tool, which does the same thing and also tracks what happens next.
Google says checking a report typically takes several days. In the Reviews Management Tool the status shows as decision pending, report reviewed with no policy violation, or escalated (in which case check your email). If Google finds no violation, you get a one-time appeal through the same tool, and you can include up to ten reviews in it. Google emails you the result.
While you wait, reply to the review anyway. If it comes down, the reply goes with it. If it stays up, you haven’t left it sitting there unanswered for a week.
When it is a scam, not a customer
There’s one case where you shouldn’t reply as if it were a real customer. Google has a help page on extortion scams: a sudden run of one-star and two-star reviews, followed by someone demanding money or favours to make them go away.
Google’s advice is not to engage with them or pay them, because paying can invite more attempts and doesn’t guarantee the reviews come down. Take screenshots of the demand with the dates, times and contact details showing, save links to the suspicious reviews, and note when the reviews started and when the demand arrived. Then report it through Google’s merchant extortion report form, which that page links to. Google says its team investigates and tells you the result, though not the details.
Facebook works a bit differently
Facebook calls reviews recommendations, and the same reply-once approach works there. Meta’s help centre says you can report a recommendation that doesn’t follow its Community Standards, and that Facebook may remove it if it doesn’t. You’ll find the report option in the menu on the review itself.
You can also switch recommendations off in your Page settings, but read the small print first. Facebook’s help page says turning them off disables recommendations and removes the rating and reviews from your Page. That means every good review goes along with the bad one. For a single bad review, we wouldn’t do it. Reply, report it if it breaks the rules, and let the good ones around it do the talking.
The menus on Facebook move around, so if the steps don’t match what you see, Meta’s own help page has the current version.
What to do next
Open your Google Business Profile today, find the oldest bad review that hasn’t got a reply, and answer it using the shape above. Then start building up a steady flow of new reviews, which our guide on getting more Google reviews without breaking the rules covers step by step. If you’d like a second pair of eyes on how your reviews and replies look to a stranger, our free check-up looks over the lot.
Sources
- Google Business Profile Help, Tips to get more reviews
- Google Business Profile Help, Manage customer reviews
- Google Maps user contributed content policy, Prohibited and restricted content
- Google Business Profile Help, Report inappropriate reviews on your Business Profile
- Google Business Profile Help, Report negative review extortion scams
- Facebook Help Centre, Turn Recommendations on or off for your business Page
- Facebook Help Centre, Report a Recommendation or review about a business Page
- Meta Business Help Centre